RSS What is this?
Back to Blog Main Page Previous Post:
This Old House on NPR!
Next Post:
What we're learning

We really oughta ...

October 13, 2009

garage, new garage, renovation, demolish, tom silva, this old house, newton centre, budgets, demolishing a garage, don't try this at home, newton centre

We'd heard it all before. We'd been warned by friends, seasoned renovators—even by Tom Silva himself: The most dangerous words you can hear from your contractor while renovating your house are, "We really oughta..." or "We might as well..." 

We tried to take this to heart, especially since there's not a lot of leeway in our budget for major add-ons, especially after some of the surprise "extras" we incurred early on in the process.

But the garage? From the beginning, this was a sticking point for us. Were we really going to end a project of this magnitude, including straightening the driveway, without somehow addressing the garage problem?  Our leaky, rusty, rickety, mildewed garage didn't seem to be in keeping with the new structure that would be going up a few feet away. As construction progressed, the problem became more and more obvious.

So the garage has to go. However, the other day, Tom came up with an innovative "solution" to demolishing it. Why not just back up the dump truck into the garage, raise the back, and drive it away? All I can say is, folks, don't try this at home...

Posted by Gillian Pierce | Categories: Newton Centre 2009 | Permalink
Comment on this Blog

(8) Comments

How about some more details on this because I can see this dump truck plan working well at all. For starters, dump trucks lift at an angle so I would expect the garage to simply slide down on the slab. Then, if for some reason the garage stayed on the truck, it surely wouldn't be safe to drive that way.

Posted by: Mike | October 13, 2009 at 01:26 PM

Check that I "can't" see it working well...

Posted by: Mike | October 13, 2009 at 01:27 PM

Yikes! Will this be on camera?

Posted by: Gillian's mom | October 13, 2009 at 10:14 PM

That was quite interesting and innovative solution by Tom.
J.Lewis
http://www.marblecityca.com

Posted by: Kitchen Countertops | October 15, 2009 at 01:50 AM

I am so happy that the garage is going....it also needs to be moved off the addition toward the street...but it doesn't look like there is room as I think that this is a corner lot??

Posted by: Dee | October 19, 2009 at 05:53 PM

We just closed two weeks ago on a very similar 1920 Dutch colonial in Montgomery County, MD. We have similar needs and desire to renovate and don’t know where to start…or just wait. Of course as a new home owner of an old Dutch colonial, I was very excited to read that This Old House was doing a feature on a sister house. But when I saw your picture and realized that it was people I actually know, I was blown away!!! Good luck with the renovation. I can’t wait to pick up some tips from your experience.

Posted by: Joe Traini | October 21, 2009 at 08:51 PM

Hi

My name is Evie Simpson. I've just visited your website http://oldhousemyhouse.thisoldhouse.com/ and I was wondering if you'd be interested in exchanging links with my website. I can offer you a HOME PAGE link back from my Industrial Supply website which is
http://www.angusandannie.com/ with page rank 5

If you are interested, please add the following information to your website and kindly let me know when it's ready. I'll do the same for you in less than 24 hours, otherwise you can delete my link from your site.

Title: Construction Machinery
URL: http://www.priorityplant.com/
Description: A wide range of quality new and used construction machinery from Priority Plant.

I hope you have a nice day and thank you for your time.

Best regards;

Evie Simpson
Web Marketing Consultant
evie.simpson@angusandannie.com


PLEASE NOTE THAT THIS IS NOT A SPAM OR AUTOMATED EMAIL, IT'S ONLY A REQUEST FOR A LINK EXCHANGE. YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS HAS NOT BEEN ADDED TO ANY LISTS, AND YOU WILL NOT BE CONTACTED AGAIN.IF YOU'D LIKE TO MAKE SURE WE DON'T CONTACT YOU AGAIN, PLEASE FILL IN THE FOLLOWING FORM:HTTP://WWW.NOMOREMAILS.COM; OR WRITE AN EMAIL TO STOP@NOMOREMAILS.COM.
PLEASE ACCEPT OUR APOLOGIES FOR CONTACTING YOU.

Posted by: Evie Simpson | October 22, 2009 at 11:46 AM

I have to say the idea, in theory, sounds like a good one. However, if a contractor does give you the "we might as well" line, it is always a good idea to get them to verbalize the plan of execution prior. Sometimes talking out the plan reveals its extreme shortcomings and prevents it from being executed.

The only downside to this thinking: you don't get great pictures like the one above.

Justin Howe

Posted by: Justin Howe | October 31, 2009 at 12:16 AM

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Roxbury Project

Newton Centre Project

New York City Project

Weston Project

New Orleans Project

Austin Project

East Boston Project

Archives

Advertisement

This Old House Blogs

In The Magazine


Expand your knowledge about topics covered in the print edition of This Old House.

AMERICA'S MOST TRUSTED HOME IMPROVEMENT BRAND
Underwriters: